How to Tell the Difference Between Cast and Extruded Acrylic
When working with acrylic materials, understanding the difference between cast and extruded acrylic is crucial for selecting the right material for your project. While both are made from the same basic polymer (polymethyl methacrylate or PMMA), their manufacturing processes create distinctly different properties that affect performance, appearance, and cost.
Manufacturing Process: The Foundation of Difference
Cast acrylic is created by pouring liquid acrylic resin between two sheets of glass, then allowing it to cure slowly in an oven. This process, which can take several hours, allows the material to form without external pressure, resulting in a more relaxed molecular structure.
Extruded acrylic, on the other hand, is manufactured by forcing heated acrylic resin through rollers in a continuous process. The material is shaped under pressure and cooled rapidly, creating internal stresses within the polymer structure. This high-volume manufacturing method makes extruded acrylic significantly less expensive to produce.
Visual and Physical Identification Methods
Edge Quality and Flame Polishing
One of the most reliable ways to distinguish between the two types is by examining how they respond to flame polishing. Cast acrylic edges become crystal clear and glass-like when flame polished, creating a beautiful, transparent finish. Extruded acrylic edges, however, remain somewhat cloudy or hazy even after flame polishing due to its internal stress patterns.
Optical Clarity
Cast acrylic offers superior optical clarity with minimal distortion, making it ideal for applications where visual quality is paramount. When you look through cast acrylic, images appear sharp and undistorted. Extruded acrylic may show slight optical distortion, particularly in thicker sheets, and generally has a less pristine appearance.
Surface Quality
Cast acrylic typically has a smoother, more uniform surface with fewer imperfections. The slower curing process allows bubbles and impurities to rise to the surface or dissipate. Extruded acrylic may show flow lines or slight surface variations from the manufacturing process.
Performance Characteristics
Machining and Fabrication
Cast acrylic machines beautifully, producing smooth cuts and clean edges with minimal chipping or cracking. It's more forgiving during drilling, routing, and other fabrication processes. The material also glues well, creating strong, nearly invisible joints.
Extruded acrylic is more prone to stress cracking during machining, especially near cut edges. It requires more careful handling and may need stress relief through annealing after fabrication. The internal stresses can cause the material to crack unexpectedly, particularly when subjected to solvents or thermal cycling.
Thermal Properties
Cast acrylic has better thermal stability and is less likely to warp or distort when exposed to temperature changes. Its relaxed molecular structure provides more uniform expansion and contraction.
Extruded acrylic's internal stresses make it more susceptible to thermal distortion. It may warp or bow when exposed to heat, and the stress patterns can become visible under certain lighting conditions.
Chemical Resistance
Both materials offer good chemical resistance, but cast acrylic generally performs better when exposed to solvents or cleaning chemicals. The stress patterns in extruded acrylic can create weak points where chemical attack is more likely to occur.
Cost Considerations and Applications
Extruded acrylic costs significantly less than cast acrylic, making it attractive for budget-conscious projects or applications where the superior properties of cast acrylic aren't necessary. It works well for simple protective barriers, basic signage, or temporary installations.
Cast acrylic commands a premium price but delivers superior performance for demanding applications. It's the preferred choice for optical applications, high-end displays, architectural features, and any project where clarity, durability, and appearance are critical.
Making the Right Choice
Choose cast acrylic when you need maximum optical clarity, superior machinability, better thermal stability, or when the application demands the highest quality appearance. It's essential for projects involving flame polishing, complex fabrication, or exposure to challenging environmental conditions.
Select extruded acrylic for cost-sensitive projects where basic acrylic properties are sufficient. It works well for simple protective applications, basic signage, or situations where the material won't undergo significant fabrication or stress.
In our store, we sell only cast acrylic! Check out our collections!
Quick Identification Tips
When examining acrylic material, look for manufacturer markings or certificates that specify the type. If documentation isn't available, perform a small flame polish test on a waste edge - cast acrylic will become crystal clear while extruded acrylic remains cloudy. Additionally, the material under stress-viewing conditions will be examined using polarized light, revealing the stress patterns characteristic of extruded acrylic.
Understanding these differences ensures you select the right acrylic type for your specific application, balancing performance requirements with budget constraints while achieving the best possible results for your project.