CO₂ vs. Diode vs. Fiber: Acrylic Cutting Guide

Laser cutting technology has revolutionized manufacturing, crafting, and design since its development in the 1960s. Different laser types excel at cutting specific materials, making it crucial to understand their capabilities when working with materials like acrylic sheets. This guide examines the main types of lasers and what they can effectively cut.

1. Diode Lasers

Wavelength: 405-450nm (blue) or 808-1064nm (infrared)

Power Range: Typically 1-20W for hobbyist machines, up to 100w for industrial systems

Materials That Cut Well:

  • Thin wood (3-6mm)
  • Paper and cardboard
  • Leather
  • Fabric
  • Some plastics (including dark colored acrylic)
  • Foam

Materials to Avoid:

  • Metal (except for thin aluminum with high-power systems)
  • Glass
  • Clear acrylic (passes through without cutting)
  • Ceramics
  • Stone

Acrylic Cutting Capability: Diode lasers can cut dark-colored acrylic up to about 3mm thickness, but struggle with clear or light-colored acrylic as the beam passes through transparent materials without sufficient energy absorption.

Advantages:

  • Most affordable laser technology
  • Compact size
  • Low power requirements
  • Minimal maintenance

Disadvantages:

  • Limited cutting power
  • Slower cutting speeds
  • Cannot cut thicker materials
  • Limited material compatibility

2. CO₂ Lasers

Wavelength: 10,600nm (far infrared)

Power Range: 30W to 400W+ (hobbyist to industrial)

Materials That Cut Well:

  • All types of acrylic (both clear and colored)
  • Wood (up to 25mm)
  • Paper and cardboard
  • Leather
  • Fabric
  • Most plastics
  • Foam
  • Glass (engraving only)
  • Stone (engraving only)
  • Coated metals (engraving only)

Materials to Avoid:

  • Raw metals (except very thin with high power)
  • Polycarbonate (produces harmful fumes)
  • PVC (releases chlorine gas)
  • Vinyl (toxic fumes)

Acrylic Cutting Capability: CO₂ lasers are ideal for all acrylic sheets. They produce clean, polished edges on both cast and extruded acrylic and can handle thicknesses from 1mm to 25mm (depending on laser power).

Advantages:

  • Versatile for numerous materials
  • Excellent for acrylic work
  • Produces clean, polished edges
  • Faster than diode lasers
  • Precision cutting and engraving

Disadvantages:

  • More expensive than diode lasers
  • Requires water cooling
  • Larger footprint
  • More maintenance requirements
  • Cannot cut metals effectively

3. Fiber Lasers

Wavelength: 1,060-1,070nm (near infrared)

Power Range: 500W to 20kW (primarily industrial)

Materials That Cut Well:

  • All metals (steel, stainless steel, aluminum, copper, brass)
  • Some engineered plastics
  • Carbon fiber
  • Some ceramics
  • Dark acrylic (though not ideal)

Materials to Avoid:

  • Clear acrylic (inefficient)
  • Wood (burns excessively)
  • Many plastics (melts rather than cuts)
  • Glass

Acrylic Cutting Capability: Fiber lasers can cut dark acrylic, but are inefficient with clear acrylic. They're rarely used for acrylic work as they tend to produce melted edges rather than the clean cuts of CO₂ lasers.

Advantages:

  • Extremely powerful for metal cutting
  • Up to 5x faster than CO₂ for metals
  • Low maintenance
  • Energy efficient
  • Smaller footprint than comparable CO₂ systems
  • Long service life (up to 100,000 hours)

Disadvantages:

  • Very expensive
  • Not versatile for non-metal materials
  • Poor performance on clear plastics like acrylic
  • Primarily industrial applications

4. Other Laser Types

UV Lasers

Wavelength: 355nm (ultraviolet)

Best For: Micro-machining, extremely precise cutting of sensitive materials, circuit boards, and medical devices

Acrylic Capability: Can cut thin acrylic with exceptional precision, but is too specialized and expensive for standard acrylic work.

Crystal Lasers (Nd)

Wavelength: 1,064nm (near infrared)

Best For: Marking metals, welding, some cutting applications

Acrylic Capability: Limited - primarily used for marking rather than cutting acrylic.

Green Lasers

Wavelength: 532nm (visible green)

Best For: Precision work on semiconductors, specialized applications

Acrylic Capability: Can mark acrylic, but not commonly used for cutting due to cost and specialization.

Which Laser Is Best for Acrylic Sheets?

For acrylic cutting, CO₂ lasers are undoubtedly the optimal choice. They offer:

  1. Clean, polished edges on all acrylic types
  2. Compatibility with clear and colored acrylic
  3. Ability to both cut and engrave with the same machine
  4. Versatility across different thicknesses
  5. Reasonable operating costs compared to more specialized laser types

For hobbyists or small businesses focusing primarily on dark acrylic in thin sheets (3mm or less), a powerful diode laser might suffice as a budget option. However, for professional results across all acrylic types, a CO₂ laser with at least 40w of power is recommended.

Fiber lasers, while revolutionary for metal cutting, are generally not cost-effective choices for acrylic work despite their advanced technology.

Back to blog